Two key NFT and web3 domain identify tasks in the sector, Ethereum Name Service and Unstoppable Domains, are in dispute in excess of patent rights. The neighborhood is also divided on each sides.
Ethereum Name Service and Unstoppable Domains have erupted into a dispute in excess of patent rights
For the previous number of days, the neighborhood has been abuzz in excess of the ongoing controversy in between Ethereum Name Service (ENS) and Unstoppable Domains, which are regarded as two rivals in the NFT domain identify section.
It all begun when the lead developer of ENS, Nick Johnson, posted on X (the outdated Twitter) the patent copyright story in between the two events.
An Open Letter RE: Blockchain Domain Name Patents
Since its founding in 2017, ENS has been a constant and outspoken advocate for open supply, open requirements, and the significance of governing the worldwide namespace as a public excellent.
—nick.eth (@nicksdjohnson) November 16, 2023
The primary conflict of the situation is due to the absolutely opposite improvement orientations in between the two tasks. ENS, founded in 2017, usually supports open supply and retains all copyrights of items with open supply licenses.
This usually means that all innovations and technologies formulated by the ENS group are available to everybody. Other tasks can freely exploit the open supply code of these initiatives to additional build their very own items.
Meanwhile, in complete contrast, Unstoppable Domains was born in 2018 with closed supply code and usually demands copyright for its inventions.
In January 2024, the Unstoppable Domains group utilized for copyright for the Resolving Blockchain Domains initiative. However, in accordance to Nick Johnson, this “initiative” is absolutely a merchandise based mostly on the technologies that ENS has previously formulated and publicly announced, but the Unstoppable Domains group has not additional any more creativity or enhancements.
Furthermore, Unstoppable Domains continues to apply for copyright with an “initiative” just about equivalent to the “Sunrise Phase” technologies that has been so acquainted for some time in the DNS (Domain Name System) planet.
Subsequently, beneath the “copyright” of Resolving Blockchain Domains, this task produced an organization known as Web3 Domain Alliance (approximately translated: Web3 Domain Alliance) and published a PR posting confirming its patent copyrights.
Unable to accept this kind of actions, ENS desires to have a dialogue with Unstoppable Domains, asking them to take away the PR posts and respect the open supply traits and open initiatives of the complete sector.
Instead, Unstoppable Domains just “invited” the ENS to join its newly formed Alliance.
Therefore, publicizing the “goodwill dialogue” in between the two events on social networks, Nick Johnson also stated that the ENS is ready to “challenge the patent” that Unstoppable Domains has registered for copyright.
ENS stays committed to open innovation in web3. We feel in setting up extensible and extended-lasting methods, open to all, to establish on and support strengthen the ecosystem of the blockchain domain.
—nick.eth (@nicksdjohnson) November 16, 2023
“ENS continues to be committed to open innovation in the web3 space. We believe in building scalable and durable systems accessible to all, together with the community Let’s join hands to help build the blockchain domain name ecosystem.”
Under Nick’s submit, Unstoppable Domains founder Matthew Gould did not make clear considerably and continued to “invite” him to join the alliance:
Hi Nick, thanks for taking the time to have these conversations with us in excess of the final couple of months. We proceed to give an open invitation to join the web3 domain alliance and encourage the web3 identify for all methods, not just ENS. Just as ICANN was crucial to DNS, the requirements bodies…
— matt.x (@matthewegould) November 16, 2023
“We proceed to inquire that tasks join the web3 Domain Name Alliance, not just ENS.
We hope that there will be participation from “competitors” ready to proceed creating the discipline of web3 domain names.”
The neighborhood is also divided on which side to assistance.
And you, are you on the side of ENS or Unstoppable Domains in this debate?
Join the discussion on the hottest difficulties in the DeFi industry in the chat group Coinlive Chats Let’s join the administrators of Coinlive!!!